Join us for Easter at St Ben's

St Benedict's Catholic Community

Reflections

Curious Catholic #8: How could a loving God allow Hell to exist?

September 7, 2020

Author name

Br Lawrence Yuen MGL

Type

Curious Catholic

Article Number

8

Body

Perhaps an image from C.S. Lewis’ The Chronicles of Narnia: The Last Battle may help shed some light on this important question. At the end of this great seven-part Christian allegory, there is a scene that resembles what we might call the Day of Judgement. In it, all the magical animals of Narnia are lining up to walk through a special Door, in which the great lion king Aslan is standing. As they approach Aslan, they can’t help but look straight into his face. When they did this, some animals hated it and finding it repulsive, automatically swerve to Aslan’s left into his huge black shadow. They were never heard of again. Other animals looked at Aslan’s face and delighted in it, and these walked through the Door on Aslan’s right. They entered the New Narnia.

While this is only a fictional image, it may be helpful to see Aslan as Christ, the black shadow as hell, the Door as heaven and the animals as us. It is worth asking: who sentences who into the black shadow of Aslan? The animals were the ones who hated Aslan’s face and found it repulsive, preferring the shadow instead. But what does this mean for us? God is love, and if in this lifetime we’ve already rejected the truths of love—e.g. mercy, forgiveness, compassion, truth, faithfulness—it would seem quite unlikely we'll suddenly embrace Love Himself when we see him face to face. Won’t we also automatically find God repulsive, and turn away into his shadow? This turning away is a useful image for hell. St. John of the Cross reminds us that “in the evening of life, we will be judged on love alone.” Because God is love, heaven is love, and the only thing that will ‘make it’ into heaven is love.

Pondering point: where am I currently turning away from the things of love—the things of heaven?

Connect to our online community

St Benedict's Catholic Community / 301 Warrigal Rd, Burwood Victoria, Australia

Call +61 3 9808 2492email: [email protected]

St Benedict's Catholic Church is committed to the safety, wellbeing and human dignity of children, young people and adults.