Reflections
Curious Catholic #6: Has the Catholic Church ever been in support of slavery?
September 7, 2020
Author name
Br Lawrence Yuen MGLType
Curious Catholic
Article Number
6
Body
No it hasn’t, however we need to flesh out this answer. If we take slavery to mean the ownership of persons or racial groups against their will for economic gain, then slavery has existed in some form since humanity’s earliest recorded history. However, church teaching has consistently condemned the practice. Whether it was St. Augustine of Hippo during the Roman Empire, Pope Gregory XVI (1591) during the European colonisation of the New World or Pope Benedict XIV (1741) during the Atlantic African slave trade era, the message has been consistent: slavery is a violation of the dignity of man made in God’s image. Hence even early church records report the habit of Christians buying slaves in order to free them again.
Why then, do some historians accuse the church of once being in support of slavery? Firstly, the practice of owning slaves is often deeply embedded in the economic and political structure of a nation. Aside from Christendom Europe—where slavery was all but abolished—the church’s influence on the economy of its nation states were often limited by the powers of the state. To see a nominally ‘Catholic’ nation still practicing slavery could appear tantamount to condoning the practice … and fair enough! Secondly, it’s always possible that individual Catholics or influential Catholic enterprises themselves chose to keep slavery going, against the clear teachings of the church. An example of this would be sects of Spanish colonists who enslaved the native peoples in the Americas (even while many religious orders fought for their humane treatment). In such instances, we need to recognise the wilful blindness and silence on the part of the prevailing church culture—maybe even church leadership—which should have been upholding the divine dignity of all people.
Pondering point: What ethical issues could prevailing church culture be wilfully blind to today? How might I be invited to speak or act out?