Reflections
Curious Catholic #13: Is everything the Pope says infallible (i.e. incapable of error)?
September 7, 2020
Author name
Br Lawrence Yuen MGLType
Curious Catholic
Article Number
13
Body
No it’s not. It may be helpful to first distinguish between the pope as a man, and the pope as the office (‘office’ in this sense meaning a position, not a room). The pope as a man is the Argentinian Jorge Bergoglio, a sinner like all of us, prone to human error and poor judgement. The pope as the office however, is appointed by Jesus through his church to be the successor of St. Peter. When the pope speaks through this office, his teaching holds far more authority, for any authority from the successors of St. Peter comes from Jesus himself. It is rightfully a supernatural authority, given by the Holy Spirit, to guide the church till Christ returns.
But even so, when the pope is speaking through his office, is everything he says infallible? Not necessarily, and context is very important here. For example, when the pope, joined with all his bishops makes a statement on faith and morals (an example of what’s called the extraordinary magisterium), these teachings hold the highest possible moral weighting for all the church. If the pope teaches on faith and morals in an encyclical—this authority is an example of the ordinary magisterium —the church are required to assent to its teachings, however the moral weighting is not as great as that of an extraordinary magisterium. On the other hand, if the pope comments about a particular movie to a journalist, we can still listen to his comments with respect, but he is unlikely intending to speak through the office of pope.
You may be surprised that what people typically understand as ‘absolute’ papal infallibility —when the pope speaks ex-cathedra—has only ever been used twice in the entire history of the church, both regarding doctrines about Mother Mary!
Pondering point: how might the teaching authority of the church square with individual conscience?