Reflections
Curious Catholic #12: Do I really have free will?
September 7, 2020
Author name
Br Lawrence Yuen MGLType
Curious Catholic
Article Number
12
Body
Some argue that because God already ‘knows’ our every action in the future, free-will is only an illusion. But the fact is, just because God knows something doesn’t mean he causes it, any more than a parent knowing their little baby will hurt them in the future causes them to do so.
Catholics maintain it is God who in fact wills our free-will. We are made in the image of a God who is love (1 John 4:16), which means our highest purpose is also to love. Yet, a condition of love is actually free-will. To be able to love, we must also have the freedom to choose not to love. If God forced us to love him automatically (i.e. he took away our free will in the matter), then we would be more akin to pre-programmed robots than human beings. Now, you might argue that God could have created us that way, but that would contradict his very nature, which is love. For love by definition cannot exist without free-will.
Importantly however, the capacity to use our free-will can be shaped by our repeated choices. The more we choose to sin for example, the more our freedom is eroded away, and the more we experience enslavement to sin (think Sméagol and the ring in The Lord of the Rings). Likewise, the more we choose to love God, the more we experience the freedom of the virtues leading our decisions towards love.
Pondering point: In which parts of my life have I discarded the free use of my free will?