Join us for Easter at St Ben's

St Benedict's Catholic Community

Reflections

Curious Catholic #10: Can I be a good person without God?

September 7, 2020

Author name

Br Lawrence Yuen MGL

Type

Curious Catholic

Article Number

10

Body

The starting answer is yes. We probably know many non-believer friends and family who are in fact outstandingly good and moral people. From a surface level, such people may even appear more ‘Gospel centred’ than many Christians we know; they are more loving, joyful, generous, truthful, just and conscientious of social injustices.

But if the above were possible—and new atheists Sam Harris and Richard Dawkins certainly think so—why bother being a Christian? Well, this question presupposes that the goal of being Christian is to be a good person. But this is not our ultimate goal. Our ultimate goal is to live in union with God, to actively seek his will, to have him be the central organising principal of our lives. Being a ‘good person’ is really but a flow-on from this. The non-believer, by definition, lacks this active relationship with God. But the Christian who omits this relationship can hardly be called a Christian!

That being said, it is always insightful to ask a non-believer on what standard they measure what they consider to be ‘good’. Their answers may vary from an objective ethical code (e.g. abiding the country’s law) to a subjective preference (e.g. ‘don’t hurt anybody’). But a Christian’s ethical code of goodness stems from a supernatural origin: whether an action or attitude conforms to the divine dignity God has given every human person. ‘Goodness’ comes from celebrating, instilling and fighting for this dignity, from womb to tomb. This is Christian goodness, and it is no trifle standard.

Pondering point: what do I take to be the defining measure of being Christian?

Connect to our online community

St Benedict's Catholic Community / 301 Warrigal Rd, Burwood Victoria, Australia

Call +61 3 9808 2492email: [email protected]

St Benedict's Catholic Church is committed to the safety, wellbeing and human dignity of children, young people and adults.