Join us for Easter at St Ben's

St Benedict's Catholic Community

Reflections

Curious Catholic #1: Do Catholics believe that all religions are ‘equal’?

September 7, 2020

Author name

Br Lawrence Yuen MGL

Type

Curious Catholic

Article Number

1

Body

There is much that is beautiful in other world religions and “the Catholic church rejects nothing of what is true and holy in these religions” (Nostra Aetate—Vatican II’s statement on interfaith dialogue). The care of the poor, the working for peace and the call to ascetic detachment are all truths the church celebrates in all major world religions.


However, the recognition of truth in all religions is not the same as saying all religions are ultimately true. Even logically this cannot be so, for Buddhists don’t believe in a personal God whereas Christians do, and Muslims believe Jesus is only a prophet, whereas Christians believe that he is the Son of God! Logically, they cannot all be equally true. Further, Christianity makes the unique claim that God himself has entered documented human history! No other religion makes this claim. Their founders and teachers may teach a way to live, a way to God, but Jesus alone points to himself, saying that he is the Way, the Truth and the Life (Jn 14:16). Christians therefore believe that what is partially true in all religions finds their full fruition in Jesus, who claims to be Truth itself.
Oftentimes, we become tempted to slip into a sort of religious pluralism because we want to avoid being perceived as arrogant. While this is understandable, the most fruitful way to actually have interfaith dialogue is to both (i) affirm what values and truths we hold in common and (ii) lovingly present what we believe Christ said to be true.
Pondering point: Why do you think God permits the existence of so many world religions?

Connect to our online community

St Benedict's Catholic Community / 301 Warrigal Rd, Burwood Victoria, Australia

Call +61 3 9808 2492email: [email protected]

St Benedict's Catholic Church is committed to the safety, wellbeing and human dignity of children, young people and adults.